fantasy football bold predictions sleepers breakouts iheart radio the fantasy football show

Subscribe to The Fantasy Football Show.

Was just offered this for Zeke?

fjh1379fjh1379 Posts: 126
Was offered M.Evans, L.Miller, Henderson, and Penny for Elliot

Wentz, Winston
Cmac,Kamara, Elliott, Hunt, Harris, Samuals
Hopkins, Hill, Jeffery, Parker, N.Harry, AJ Brown
Kelce, Henry

Comments

  • fjh1379fjh1379 Posts: 126
    Any thoughts?
  • XtremeXtreme Posts: 4,172
    I'd take that offer.
  • rabidbucfanrabidbucfan Posts: 3,613
    I'd take that as well. Evans moves in to start, Hendy may prove to be your RB3 and if Penny is healthy he can be a hidden assest. L. Miller well he plays football. lol He's a starter I know but he's way down on your bench. Maybe you can use him and someone to upgrade your QB. AJ Brown adp has him as 1.04 pick and L. Miller for Baker Baker Touchdown Maker Mayfield or Wentz/Miller for Mayfield just a thought.
    "The only place success comes before work is the dictionary" ~Vince Lombardi
    Mod - Sleeper U
  • IcemanIceman Posts: 4,441
    Agree, go with it.
  • TheDudeTheDude Posts: 1,867
    Pile on. I would take that deal

  • chuckeycharleschuckeycharles Posts: 5,602
    edited June 8
    Starting requirements and scoring?

    If No-PPR and can start McCaffrey, Kamara and Zeke then it is a nope for me
    10 Team Dynasty - All TDs = 6 / PassingYd = .04 / Rushing-ReceivingYd = .10 / No-PPR / No Bonus
    - - - - - - - - - - - Starting requirements = QB - RB - RB/WR - WR - WR/TE - TE - DST - K
    QB - Wilson, Luck, J. Allen, Carr, Rosen / RB - Zeke, Kamara, DJ, Bell, D.Cook, Samuels, Guice, L.Miller, D.Foreman
    WR - Hopkins, M.Thomas, AJG, A.Miller, Godwin, M.Williams, Foster / TE - Gronk, Gesicki, OJHoward, JonnuSmith
    DST - Ravens, Vikings / K - Lutz
    12 Team Dynasty - TDs = 4-6 / PassingYd 25=1 / Rushing-ReceivingYd 10=1 / PPR / Bonus 3 at 300-100
    - - - - - - - - - - - Starting requirements = QB - 2RB - 3WR - 1TE - 1FlexRWT - DST - K
    QB - Cousins, Trubisky, Darnold / RB - DJ, Ingram, K.Johnson, A.Jones, Crowell, JamaalWilliams, M.Davis, D.Harris, R.Armstead, A.Barnes
    WR - Hopkins, K.Allen, DK.Metcalf, Boykin, Westbrook, Humphries, DavidMoore, Cole, Sharpe, Baldwin / TE - Gronk, Walker, Gesicki, Hurst, V.McDonald, Dissley
    DST - Steelers / K - Lutz
  • TBLTBL Posts: 787
    I personally would not trade Zeke for that. I’d stick with the 3 headed monster at RB over Evans and 3 question marks.
  • ffbfan06ffbfan06 Posts: 114
    I'd say no
  • farfromhomefarfromhome Posts: 1,275
    TBL said:

    I personally would not trade Zeke for that. I’d stick with the 3 headed monster at RB over Evans and 3 question marks.


    This. Your trading a top 3 proven workhorse rb in his prime for a top 5 wr and a couple questions marks....look...i get this place loves henderson but he is a question mark still... I also love penny but he is also a question mark...why mess up McCaffrey.. Kamara... Elliott.. Your roster is fat..... Go win a championship
  • fjh1379fjh1379 Posts: 126
    10 team full PPR dynasty
    We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1FLEX
  • chuckeycharleschuckeycharles Posts: 5,602
    fjh1379 said:

    10 team full PPR dynasty
    We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1FLEX

    NOPE. Start all 3 RBs and play for the championship for the next 3 or 4 years.
    10 Team Dynasty - All TDs = 6 / PassingYd = .04 / Rushing-ReceivingYd = .10 / No-PPR / No Bonus
    - - - - - - - - - - - Starting requirements = QB - RB - RB/WR - WR - WR/TE - TE - DST - K
    QB - Wilson, Luck, J. Allen, Carr, Rosen / RB - Zeke, Kamara, DJ, Bell, D.Cook, Samuels, Guice, L.Miller, D.Foreman
    WR - Hopkins, M.Thomas, AJG, A.Miller, Godwin, M.Williams, Foster / TE - Gronk, Gesicki, OJHoward, JonnuSmith
    DST - Ravens, Vikings / K - Lutz
    12 Team Dynasty - TDs = 4-6 / PassingYd 25=1 / Rushing-ReceivingYd 10=1 / PPR / Bonus 3 at 300-100
    - - - - - - - - - - - Starting requirements = QB - 2RB - 3WR - 1TE - 1FlexRWT - DST - K
    QB - Cousins, Trubisky, Darnold / RB - DJ, Ingram, K.Johnson, A.Jones, Crowell, JamaalWilliams, M.Davis, D.Harris, R.Armstead, A.Barnes
    WR - Hopkins, K.Allen, DK.Metcalf, Boykin, Westbrook, Humphries, DavidMoore, Cole, Sharpe, Baldwin / TE - Gronk, Walker, Gesicki, Hurst, V.McDonald, Dissley
    DST - Steelers / K - Lutz
  • Hawk12Hawk12 Posts: 3,297
    fjh1379 said:

    10 team full PPR dynasty
    We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1FLEX

    Was offered M.Evans, L.Miller, Henderson, and Penny for Elliot



    Right here is why it helps very much to include starting reqs and PPR/nonPPR, and how many teams are in your league..... THis was a most likely yes, till you posted SHORTER starting Reqs while NONE of the guys you'd be getting for Zeke will start other than Evans.

    You already have depth for the starting reqs of this league, and you'd go from Zeke to Evans in the lineup, and give another owner a great RB1 when he prob doesn't have one....

    This is now a firm NO, do not take that trade & start the guys in bold and smile....

    Wentz, Winston
    Cmac,Kamara, Elliott, Hunt, Harris, Samuals
    Hopkins, Hill, Jeffery, Parker, N.Harry, AJ Brown (Jeffrrey is Hill susp, N'Keal next year if Hill still susp.)
    Kelce, Henry

    Firm NO on that offer with more info @fjh1379
  • chuckeycharleschuckeycharles Posts: 5,602
    edited June 10
    Hawk12 said:

    fjh1379 said:

    10 team full PPR dynasty
    We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1FLEX

    Was offered M.Evans, L.Miller, Henderson, and Penny for Elliot



    Right here is why it helps very much to include starting reqs and PPR/nonPPR, and how many teams are in your league..... THis was a most likely yes, till you posted SHORTER starting Reqs while NONE of the guys you'd be getting for Zeke will start other than Evans.

    You already have depth for the starting reqs of this league, and you'd go from Zeke to Evans in the lineup, and give another owner a great RB1 when he prob doesn't have one....

    This is now a firm NO, do not take that trade & start the guys in bold and smile....

    Wentz, Winston
    Cmac,Kamara, Elliott, Hunt, Harris, Samuals
    Hopkins, Hill, Jeffery, Parker, N.Harry, AJ Brown (Jeffrrey is Hill susp, N'Keal next year if Hill still susp.)
    Kelce, Henry

    Firm NO on that offer with more info @fjh1379
    Thanks @Hawk12 !!!

    I don't understand why anyone asks for trade advice without giving as much information as possible including their reasoning for considering such a trade.

    There is no standard lineup, no standard scoring no standard league size, no standard roster size. AND my favorite... No trade exists in a vacuum.

    Once again... this trade offer should be rejected
    10 Team Dynasty - All TDs = 6 / PassingYd = .04 / Rushing-ReceivingYd = .10 / No-PPR / No Bonus
    - - - - - - - - - - - Starting requirements = QB - RB - RB/WR - WR - WR/TE - TE - DST - K
    QB - Wilson, Luck, J. Allen, Carr, Rosen / RB - Zeke, Kamara, DJ, Bell, D.Cook, Samuels, Guice, L.Miller, D.Foreman
    WR - Hopkins, M.Thomas, AJG, A.Miller, Godwin, M.Williams, Foster / TE - Gronk, Gesicki, OJHoward, JonnuSmith
    DST - Ravens, Vikings / K - Lutz
    12 Team Dynasty - TDs = 4-6 / PassingYd 25=1 / Rushing-ReceivingYd 10=1 / PPR / Bonus 3 at 300-100
    - - - - - - - - - - - Starting requirements = QB - 2RB - 3WR - 1TE - 1FlexRWT - DST - K
    QB - Cousins, Trubisky, Darnold / RB - DJ, Ingram, K.Johnson, A.Jones, Crowell, JamaalWilliams, M.Davis, D.Harris, R.Armstead, A.Barnes
    WR - Hopkins, K.Allen, DK.Metcalf, Boykin, Westbrook, Humphries, DavidMoore, Cole, Sharpe, Baldwin / TE - Gronk, Walker, Gesicki, Hurst, V.McDonald, Dissley
    DST - Steelers / K - Lutz
  • CoolHandCoolHand Posts: 7,078

    Hawk12 said:

    fjh1379 said:

    10 team full PPR dynasty
    We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1FLEX

    Was offered M.Evans, L.Miller, Henderson, and Penny for Elliot



    Right here is why it helps very much to include starting reqs and PPR/nonPPR, and how many teams are in your league..... THis was a most likely yes, till you posted SHORTER starting Reqs while NONE of the guys you'd be getting for Zeke will start other than Evans.

    You already have depth for the starting reqs of this league, and you'd go from Zeke to Evans in the lineup, and give another owner a great RB1 when he prob doesn't have one....

    This is now a firm NO, do not take that trade & start the guys in bold and smile....

    Wentz, Winston
    Cmac,Kamara, Elliott, Hunt, Harris, Samuals
    Hopkins, Hill, Jeffery, Parker, N.Harry, AJ Brown (Jeffrrey is Hill susp, N'Keal next year if Hill still susp.)
    Kelce, Henry

    Firm NO on that offer with more info @fjh1379
    Thanks @Hawk12 !!!

    I don't understand why anyone asks for trade advice without giving as much information as possible including their reasoning for considering such a trade.

    There is no standard lineup, no standard scoring no standard league size, no standard roster size. AND my favorite... No trade exists in a vacuum.

    Once again... this trade offer should be rejected
    Sometimes you just want to see what others think in terms of plain value. Sometimes a roster doesn’t matter in a trade. It all depends on what the person’s plans or goals are.
    If it’s based on a starting lineup, etc... then yes I agree, it’s very helpful. It’s just my opinion 😁👍
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 10,165
    I would have given him for Evans and Hendy alone. Adding Penny is just gravy.
    I'm an asshole from:
    Montreal, Canada  image
    Also creator of this:
  • Hawk12Hawk12 Posts: 3,297
    WTCM said:

    I would have given him for Evans and Hendy alone. Adding Penny is just gravy.

    I could see that, if oyu are a bieliever that Henderson will put up near Zeke numbers right away. This is a stacked roset with short starting lineup = STUDS WIN in this set up Cmac, Kamara, Zeke will crush anything anyone can put up in value right now - so no I don;t take that at all, especially as he has DHop and Tyreek as his pther 2 starters.... Big fat no in THIS CASE> other league starting reqs (read deeper starters) - then yeah this is a take the deal. Value wise its good, starter wise it sucks
  • TheDudeTheDude Posts: 1,867
    I still take the trade. Zeke is a 300+ carry back. They don't last long. Thomas replacing Zeke as a starter is pretty good. Two lottery tickets at RB. Still a stud lineup.

  • KookaburraKookaburra Posts: 901
    Keep who you have.
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 10,165
    There is no way Hendy is putting up Zeke numbers. I don't think anyone is expecting that. But what he's getting for Zeke is enough. Jeffery is trash so its nice to have Evans
    I'm an asshole from:
    Montreal, Canada  image
    Also creator of this:
  • Hawk12Hawk12 Posts: 3,297
    I like the debate, and can see the value in the trade offer..... Fair points all around
Sign In or Register to comment.