fantasy football bold predictions sleepers breakouts fantasy football rankings cheat sheets 2016 fantasy football mock drafts 2016 fantasy football odell beckham sketch fantasy football bold predictions sleepers breakouts

Ingram, Buckner or Garrett

NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
Who do you like better at DL both for the upcoming season and long-term? Melvin Ingram, DeForest Buckner or Myles Garrett. Please rank them.

Scoring:
Sack 3 points
Tackle 1 point
Assist .50 points
Fumble 2 points (forced or recovered)
12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
K - Tucker
D/ST - Texans, Panthers
DL - Buckner
LB - Ogletree
DB - R. Jones
Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)

Comments

  • IcemanIceman Posts: 2,335
    So a strip sack is worth 6 pts if also recovered 8 pts.

    Ingram
    Garret
    Buckner
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    Thanks Iceman!
    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
  • boobam13boobam13 Posts: 1,449
    I really like Buckner this season
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    edited June 18
    Thanks boombam!
    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
  • Whos_Ur_DoggieWhos_Ur_Doggie Posts: 2,659
    Garrett, Ingram then Buckner for me.
    SleeperU Forum Moderator
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 6,891
    If only we had an IDP god that we can ask these questions too and get the correct answers from, all the freaking time... 






    #thedefiantone

    The "U's" Forum Moderator
    Montreal, Canada
    Proud Canadian  image
    Also creator of this:
  • CoolHand Posts: 4,444
    Is Danielle Hunter available? If so, I'd take him above all of them! He's also apparently taking over the starting role so watch out!!
    Otherwise Buckner, Ingram, Garrett imo
  • boobam13boobam13 Posts: 1,449
    Buckner played a ton of snaps last year as a rookie - that defense will be on the  field a lot this season too
  • Whos_Ur_DoggieWhos_Ur_Doggie Posts: 2,659
    boobam13 said:

    Buckner played a ton of snaps last year as a rookie - that defense will be on the  field a lot this season too


    49ers LE DeForest Buckner said he was "dead tired" at times as a rookie.

    Analysis: Buckner played 1,006 snaps, a number only topped by Olivier Vernon among defensive linemen, but he should get more rest this season. "When you look at a guy like Buckner last year having played almost 1,000 snaps -- in my mind, that's criminal," new DC Robert Saleh said. "Ideally, all of them are working about 500, 600 snaps and trying to utilize everything they've got every snap." Buckner said there were times he felt he was "hurting" the team because he was so drained, so the snaps off should be a welcome sight.
    SleeperU Forum Moderator
  • Wooters Posts: 52
    WTCM said:

    If only we had an IDP god that we can ask these questions too and get the correct answers from, all the freaking time... 







    #thedefiantone

    Sure thing buddy.

    This question is difficult to answer because you are talking about a rookie, and two players moving from 3-4 OLB to 4-3 DE.  So we have nothing to go on but guesswork as they are all in a similar  tier.  Probably like Buckner out of all of them, but SF won't be playing too often with a lead an thusly his sacks may be limited.  Same for Garrett.  I'd probably go Ingram, Buckner, Garrett in this situation in redraft and Garrett, Bucker, Ingram in dynasty.

    But hey, that's more insight than our resident IDP "expert" Tav will give you.  Where is Tav BTW?  How come he doesn't respond in that thread or comment endlessly in these threads?  Tav, oh Tav, where art thou?
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    CoolHand said:

    Is Danielle Hunter available? If so, I'd take him above all of them! He's also apparently taking over the starting role so watch out!!
    Otherwise Buckner, Ingram, Garrett imo

    Unfortunately Hunter is already rostered
    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    Thanks for the input fellas!

    I missed out on Garrett in our rookie draft so, it's down to Buckner & Ingram.
    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
  • boobam13boobam13 Posts: 1,449
    Buckner 

    Ingram to me is more name value and hasn't done anything special as of yet.

    How many DE/DT do you guys start?
  • IcemanIceman Posts: 2,335
    All three of these guys are close. The reason I see Ingram ahead of Buckner is he has always been an edge rusher but scored and used as a LB as well, that helped his tackle totals but hurt his sacks some. He will be playing full time hand in the dirt moving forward on a team that will be leading or competitive in most of the games they play. Buckner's team is going to be playing from behind much more hurting his sack opportunities even though he may be on the field more.
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    boobam13 said:

    Buckner 


    Ingram to me is more name value and hasn't done anything special as of yet.

    How many DE/DT do you guys start?

    It is a partial IDP, we only start 1 at DL

    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
  • boobam13boobam13 Posts: 1,449
    can we see a list of who is already rostered?
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    boobam13 said:

    can we see a list of who is already rostered?



    J.J Watt
    Oliver Vernon
    Joey Bosa
    Aaron Donald
    Danielle Hunter
    Calais Campbell
    Everson Griffen
    Carlos Dunlap
    Frank Clark
    Cameron Jordan
    DeForest Buckner
    Leonard Williams
    Ndamukong Suh
    Malik Jackson
    Myles Garrett

    Some of the top available names are:

    Melvin Ingram
    Jason Pierre-Paul
    Ezekiel Ansah
    Cameron Wake
    Cliff Avril
    Muhammad Wilkerson

    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
  • Wooters Posts: 52
    JPP>Ingram
  • boobam13boobam13 Posts: 1,449
    Agree - and with so few starting requirements I would find a guy for a few weeks and see who is there after week 4 to improve on. Looks like your league doesn't have heavy investment in DL which is nice for you to plug and play 
  • IcemanIceman Posts: 2,335
    Would like Ansah over Ingram as well.
  • NorthwoodsNorthwoods Posts: 79
    Thanks again fellas, much appreciated!
    12 Team Dynasty (Standard PPR Scoring)
    QB - Rodgers, Prescott, Bortles
    RB - McCoy, Howard, Blount, Gillislee, Powell, Thompson, Charles, McGuire
    WR - Hopkins, Tate, Maclin, Cobb, J. Brown, Woods, Conley
    TE - Reed, J. Graham, Walker, Fiedorowicz
    K - Tucker
    D/ST - Texans, Panthers
    DL - Buckner
    LB - Ogletree
    DB - R. Jones
    Taxi Squad - Smallwood (2nd Yr), Kamara, Smith-Schuster, Henderson
    2018 Rookie Picks - 1st (1), 2nd (2), 3rd (1) & 4th (1)
Sign In or Register to comment.