fantasy football bold predictions sleepers breakouts fantasy football rankings cheat sheets 2016 fantasy football mock drafts 2016 fantasy football odell beckham sketch fantasy football bold predictions sleepers breakouts

McCoy or D. Cook

Who would you rather have in a startup?
Dynasty Startup
  1. Who would you rather?21 votes
    1. Lesean McCoy
      52.38%
    2. Dalvin Cook
      47.62%

Heroes get remembered, but legends never die. Follow your heart, kid, and you'll never go wrong........

12 Team Dynastty 1 PPR 1QB-2RB-2WR-1TE-1FLEX-DEF-K

QB: D. Brees, C. Newton, T. Bridgewater

RB: D. Johnson, J. Ajayi, L. McCoy, M. Gillislee, A. Abdullah, R. Burkhead

WR: A. Brown, B. Cooks, L. Fitz, J. Crowder, D. Parker, T. Lockette

TE: M. Bennett, C.J. Fedz, V.McDonald

D/ST: Eagles, Panthers

K: M. Prater


12 Team Dynasty 1 PPR 1QB-2RB-2WR-1TE-1RB/WR-1Flex

QB: T. Brady, C. Newton, D. Kizer

RB: J. Ajayi, L. McCoy, D. Cook, AD, T. West, R. Burkhead, L. Murray

WR: J. Jones, D. Thomas, M. Crabtree, T. Lockette, M. Jones, C. Kupp, T. Taylor

TE: Z. Ertz, C.J. Fedz, V. McDonald

«1

Comments

  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677
    I have lesean and want Dalvin cook in our dynasty but I'm a contender and there's no way it's give shady for cook. Not a chance
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 7,686
    Start up dynasty? Cook for me.
    The "U's" Forum Moderator
    Montreal, Canada
    Proud Canadian  image
    Also creator of this:
  • McCoy. He still has 2 elite years left.
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 7,686

    McCoy. He still has 2 elite years left.

    That's being generous. In two years Cook will enter that same elite level. 
    The "U's" Forum Moderator
    Montreal, Canada
    Proud Canadian  image
    Also creator of this:
  • swampiesswampies Posts: 1,899
    WTCM said:

    Start up dynasty? Cook for me.


    this because it's a start up!
    (I'm not a expert but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night!)
    SleeperU Forum Moderator
    USA
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 7,686
    swampies said:

    WTCM said:

    Start up dynasty? Cook for me.


    this because it's a start up!
    That's right! See @Swampies is with me!
    The "U's" Forum Moderator
    Montreal, Canada
    Proud Canadian  image
    Also creator of this:
  • CamtasticCamtastic Posts: 298
    I ended up going with Cook.  I have another pick coming up, we will see if McCoy is still there

    Heroes get remembered, but legends never die. Follow your heart, kid, and you'll never go wrong........

    12 Team Dynastty 1 PPR 1QB-2RB-2WR-1TE-1FLEX-DEF-K

    QB: D. Brees, C. Newton, T. Bridgewater

    RB: D. Johnson, J. Ajayi, L. McCoy, M. Gillislee, A. Abdullah, R. Burkhead

    WR: A. Brown, B. Cooks, L. Fitz, J. Crowder, D. Parker, T. Lockette

    TE: M. Bennett, C.J. Fedz, V.McDonald

    D/ST: Eagles, Panthers

    K: M. Prater


    12 Team Dynasty 1 PPR 1QB-2RB-2WR-1TE-1RB/WR-1Flex

    QB: T. Brady, C. Newton, D. Kizer

    RB: J. Ajayi, L. McCoy, D. Cook, AD, T. West, R. Burkhead, L. Murray

    WR: J. Jones, D. Thomas, M. Crabtree, T. Lockette, M. Jones, C. Kupp, T. Taylor

    TE: Z. Ertz, C.J. Fedz, V. McDonald

  • It really comes down to wanting to go for the win right away, or wanting to build for a longer future.
  • Whos_Ur_DoggieWhos_Ur_Doggie Posts: 2,962
    WTCM said:

    McCoy. He still has 2 elite years left.

    That's being generous. In two years Cook will enter that same elite level. 
    LOL.... says who and why exactly?  What has Cook done in the NFL as of today besides get drafted by Minny?
    SleeperU Forum Moderator
  • chuckeycharleschuckeycharles Posts: 2,925
    WTCM said:

    swampies said:

    WTCM said:

    Start up dynasty? Cook for me.


    this because it's a start up!
    That's right! See @Swampies is with me!
    So is this OLD FART
      Both Leagues - Start  QB  RB  RB/WR  WR  WR/TE  TE  K  DST  All TD = 6  Pass Yd = .04  Rush-Rec Yd = .10 No-PPR  No Bonuses
    10 Team Limited Keeper (2 or 3)  10 Team Dynasty
    QB - R,Wilson, D.Brees QB - Luck, R.Wilson, D.Carr, Siemian 
    RB - Zeke, M.Gordon, Fournette, Mack, Foreman, AP, AlfMorris
    RB - Zeke, David Johnson, L.Bell, AP, Foreman, Kamara, Cohen, Smallwood, L.Murray
    WR - M.Thomas, B.Cooks, KBenj, J.Landry WR - Hopkins, Dez, AJG, B.Cooks, M.Thomas (NO), M.Jones, Hogan, A.Hurns, M.Williams, J. Ross
    TE - STREAM (ASJ) TE - Gronk, M.Bennett
    DST - STREAM (Ravens)   DST - Vikes, Ravens
    K - STREAM (Lutz)    K - STREAM (Hopkins)
  • redzoneriesredzoneries Posts: 3,046
    Cook. Next year who do yall think will be tue better back, i think its even or the edge to cook in 2018 so why pick mccoy unless you are in asevere win now
  • SMFFCNSMFFCN Posts: 1,115
    I went Cook here.

    I think McCoy still has a year or two of elite production left, but also believe that Cook will be there as well with more time to keep him on my roster.
  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677
    Quote
    CamtasticCamtastic Posts: 122
    June 8
    1.01 - David Johnson
    1.02 - Ezekiel Elliott
    1.03 - LeVeon Bell
    1.04 - Odell Beckham Jr
    1.05 - Antonio Brown
    1.06 - Julio Jones
    1.07 - Mike Evans
    1.08 - A.J. Green
    1.09 - Leonard Fournette
    1.10 - Amari Cooper
    1.11 - DeAndre Hopkins
    1.12 - Melvin Gordon

    2.01 - Michael Thomas
    2.02 - LeSean McCoy
    2.03 - Allen Robinson
    2.04 - Corey Davis
    2.05 - Rob Gronkowski
    2.06 - Devonta Freeman
    2.07 - Jordan Howard
    2.08 - Todd Gurley
    2.09 - TY HIlton
    2.10 - Jay Ajayi
    2.11 - Jordy Nelson
    2.12 - aaron rodgers

    3.01 - demaryius thomas
    3.02 - Dez Bryant

    3.03- Alshon Jeffery


    Weird to me that you guys are taking cook here when you let a whole round go by in the mock after McCoy got take #-o
  • redzoneriesredzoneries Posts: 3,046
    I would not have taken mccoy at 2.02
  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677
    edited June 15
    I think he absolutely deserves to go at 2.02. And no offense but you've built your team with a looking waaaay forward mentality. I love Cook as much or more than anyone but if you like winning money then the choice is very obviously McCoy imo.

    McCoy belongs in the tier with Gordon, Gurley and Freeman, but none of those guys have proven that they can do it year in and year out except McCoy. Even Freeman has only done t twice and he's even lost his run genius offensive coordinator so there are questions there. So while McCoy may be the oldest of his tier, he's also the safest. For those reasons I think he's actually a great value at the top of the 2nd
  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677

    I would not have taken mccoy at 2.02

    I could have kept gordon or gurley instead of McCoy but I feel like McCoy is the most talented, and at 29 I think he easily has 2 elite years left and then he'll be solid for 2 more. But CMac will be able to pick up the slack by then
  • ReisssoxReisssox Posts: 641

    I would not have taken mccoy at 2.02

    Not now...no way for me either
  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677
    Reisssox said:

    I would not have taken mccoy at 2.02

    Not now...no way for me either
    I think if you got 3 more 1200 yard season out of McCoy you'd be happy with the investment
  • I believe I took McCoy at 2.02 during that mock and I would do it again without hesitation. I don't see anyone after him that I regret passing on.
  • redzoneriesredzoneries Posts: 3,046
    Only once in mccoys career has he had back to back 1200+ yard seasons. At this point i dont see it happening again, meaning this year ita not looking great for him. Also what does my team have to do with this? Mccoy will be 29 this season, has an injury history, and is on a bad team. Not grear news for old rbs
  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677
    Not many rbs ever have had back to back 1200 yard seasons lol, not just McCoy. And I was just saying of course you would take cook over McCoy, you have 12 freakin rookies on your team lol
  • emurrell17emurrell17 Posts: 2,677
    McCoy has exponentially more back to back 1200 yard seasons than the entire rest of the tier he's in. Interesting that people are so far apart on McCoy but I completely think he deserves to be drafted at that spot. The only one who maybe has a case to be taken higher is freeman but even he has Coleman and a new oc
  • footballchixfootballchix Posts: 480
    I voted McCoy. 
    10 player keeper league QB, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, W/R/T, W/R/T, W/R/T, W/R/T, K, DEF, D, D, D, D, D,
    QB: Newton,  Dalton RB:C McCaffrey,  Kareem Hunt, M Lynch, Doug Martin, Tevin Coleman WR:OBJ, Mike Evans, T.Y. Hilton, Tyreek Hill, Corey Davis, Kenny Golladay
    TE: Delanie Walker  K: Matt Bryant  D: Houston  +  IDP: Tyrann Mathieu, Sean Lee, Vic Beasley Jr., Jatavis Brown, Terrell Suggs

    12 team keepers QB, WR, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, W/R, K, DEF, DEF, D, D, DB, DB, DL, DL,
    QB: Prescott,  Winston. RB: Elliott, D Murray, Mixon,  Kamara  TE: Gronkowski, Kittle.  WR: Michael Thomas , DeVante Parker, Brandon Marshall, Corey Coleman Corey Davis, 
    Def:  Cincinnati. Houston, K: Justin Tucker IDP : T Mathieu ,K Alexander, J Peppers, D Jones ,Jamal Adams, Calais Campbell, N Suh, Jatavis Brown
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 7,686

    WTCM said:

    McCoy. He still has 2 elite years left.

    That's being generous. In two years Cook will enter that same elite level. 
    LOL.... says who and why exactly?  What has Cook done in the NFL as of today besides get drafted by Minny?
    It's a startup, why wouldn't I want to build for the future? And who's to say the McCoy breakdown doesn't happen this year? Its not like he has any help to remove 8 in the box. Minny ain't better, but at least they're moving in the right direction. Plus good luck unloading McCoy when his value is shot.
    The "U's" Forum Moderator
    Montreal, Canada
    Proud Canadian  image
    Also creator of this:
  • swampiesswampies Posts: 1,899
    imageFor me comparing McCoy and Cook would be like starting a day with coffee that was made yesterday and yes it was good but it was from yesterday. I would prefer to start my day with a fresh cup of coffee and enjoy the fresh taste and smell. Give me Cook in a start up League.
    (I'm not a expert but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night!)
    SleeperU Forum Moderator
    USA
  • CamtasticCamtastic Posts: 298
    So, I waited, and manged to still get McCoy in the next round. I got both. Winning!

    Heroes get remembered, but legends never die. Follow your heart, kid, and you'll never go wrong........

    12 Team Dynastty 1 PPR 1QB-2RB-2WR-1TE-1FLEX-DEF-K

    QB: D. Brees, C. Newton, T. Bridgewater

    RB: D. Johnson, J. Ajayi, L. McCoy, M. Gillislee, A. Abdullah, R. Burkhead

    WR: A. Brown, B. Cooks, L. Fitz, J. Crowder, D. Parker, T. Lockette

    TE: M. Bennett, C.J. Fedz, V.McDonald

    D/ST: Eagles, Panthers

    K: M. Prater


    12 Team Dynasty 1 PPR 1QB-2RB-2WR-1TE-1RB/WR-1Flex

    QB: T. Brady, C. Newton, D. Kizer

    RB: J. Ajayi, L. McCoy, D. Cook, AD, T. West, R. Burkhead, L. Murray

    WR: J. Jones, D. Thomas, M. Crabtree, T. Lockette, M. Jones, C. Kupp, T. Taylor

    TE: Z. Ertz, C.J. Fedz, V. McDonald

  • swampiesswampies Posts: 1,899
    =D>
    (I'm not a expert but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night!)
    SleeperU Forum Moderator
    USA
  • chuckeycharleschuckeycharles Posts: 2,925
    Camtastic said:

    So, I waited, and manged to still get McCoy in the next round. I got both. Winning!

    image
      Both Leagues - Start  QB  RB  RB/WR  WR  WR/TE  TE  K  DST  All TD = 6  Pass Yd = .04  Rush-Rec Yd = .10 No-PPR  No Bonuses
    10 Team Limited Keeper (2 or 3)  10 Team Dynasty
    QB - R,Wilson, D.Brees QB - Luck, R.Wilson, D.Carr, Siemian 
    RB - Zeke, M.Gordon, Fournette, Mack, Foreman, AP, AlfMorris
    RB - Zeke, David Johnson, L.Bell, AP, Foreman, Kamara, Cohen, Smallwood, L.Murray
    WR - M.Thomas, B.Cooks, KBenj, J.Landry WR - Hopkins, Dez, AJG, B.Cooks, M.Thomas (NO), M.Jones, Hogan, A.Hurns, M.Williams, J. Ross
    TE - STREAM (ASJ) TE - Gronk, M.Bennett
    DST - STREAM (Ravens)   DST - Vikes, Ravens
    K - STREAM (Lutz)    K - STREAM (Hopkins)
  • chuckeycharleschuckeycharles Posts: 2,925
    Probably would not have gotten both if you took McCoy first
      Both Leagues - Start  QB  RB  RB/WR  WR  WR/TE  TE  K  DST  All TD = 6  Pass Yd = .04  Rush-Rec Yd = .10 No-PPR  No Bonuses
    10 Team Limited Keeper (2 or 3)  10 Team Dynasty
    QB - R,Wilson, D.Brees QB - Luck, R.Wilson, D.Carr, Siemian 
    RB - Zeke, M.Gordon, Fournette, Mack, Foreman, AP, AlfMorris
    RB - Zeke, David Johnson, L.Bell, AP, Foreman, Kamara, Cohen, Smallwood, L.Murray
    WR - M.Thomas, B.Cooks, KBenj, J.Landry WR - Hopkins, Dez, AJG, B.Cooks, M.Thomas (NO), M.Jones, Hogan, A.Hurns, M.Williams, J. Ross
    TE - STREAM (ASJ) TE - Gronk, M.Bennett
    DST - STREAM (Ravens)   DST - Vikes, Ravens
    K - STREAM (Lutz)    K - STREAM (Hopkins)
  • WTCMWTCM Posts: 7,686
    This is not a Vikings homer thing either. I would take Fournette, Cooks, McCaf, or Mixon ahead of McCoy.
    The "U's" Forum Moderator
    Montreal, Canada
    Proud Canadian  image
    Also creator of this:
Sign In or Register to comment.